Falstaff Magazine (91)- "Open and fragrant nose of fresh roses, rich raspberries and sugared strawberries. Very fine-footed on the palate, delicate, pleasant drinking flow, compact fruit, has fine red berry notes on the finish."
Wine Advocate (91)- "Prugnolo Gentile is a clone of Sangiovese that comes from the Vino Nobile di Montepulciano appellation. Giorgio Rivetti is doing a lot of work with this clone at his Tuscan property near Pisa. The 2013 Il Gentile di Casanova opens to a dark color with red cooper highlights. The aromas are raw and genuine with black fruit, spice and rusty nail. The wine offers heft and power, although it does loosen up to show pretty elegance and silkiness in terms of mouthfeel. If you are hankering for an authenthic taste of Tucany, this wine will do."
Wine Spectator (91)- "Resembles a Brunello, showing menthol, wild rosemary, eucalyptus and juniper aromas and flavors surrounding the core of cherry fruit. Still firm and unyielding, with a mix of bitterness and sweet fruit. Fine length. Sangiovese. Best from 2016 through 2025. 1,000 cases made."